• Connect With Us:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Trump Chooses Among '3 Bad Options' In Afghanistan, Former NATO Commander Says

Last Updated on

President Trump has reaffirmed the U.S. commitment to Afghanistan, America’s longest war. He outlined a new strategy Monday night that is expected to include the deployment of more American troops, but he did not specify the number. He also said there will be no timetable for the mission.

Here & Now‘s Robin Young speaks with retired Navy Adm. James Stavridis (@stavridisj), dean of the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University, about Afghanistan and also the threat posed by North Korea.

Interview Highlights

On reaction to President Trump’s address on Afghanistan

“The president had three bad options in front of him. First of all, he could cut our losses and run after 2,400 dead and $800 billion spent, and we would have ended up with helicopters lifting off the roof of the American Embassy much like we saw at the end of the war in Vietnam. … And I think you would see the descent to chaos that we saw in Vietnam, and the need for humanitarian withdrawal completely. So, bad option.

“Second option the president had: go back to the big force. When I was NATO commander I had 150,000 troops under my command in Afghanistan. That is an option for which nobody has an appetite. There’s enormous Afghan fatigue. So you’re left with that kinda middle option, which is minimalist. It increases troops by a tiny number, 4,000. We need to press our allies to match that — that’ll give us an extra 8,000 — and use the other tools that we have: putting pressure on Pakistan, working to build an Afghan air force. There are tactical things we can do, but it’s a bad option, but it’s the least-worst option the president was presented with.”

On whether Trump’s announcement marks a continuation of U.S. policy in Afghanistan

“I’ve been calling it kinda ‘back to the future,’ and I feel like we are now roughly where we were back in 2013 as we drew down from the 150,000 troops to the current number, somewhere around 12,000 total, U.S. and allied. So it is very much what we’ve done in the past. The only two new elements are, first, the idea that this will be conditions-based, not timeline-based. In other words, telling the Afghans and particularly the Taliban we are gonna stay. And then secondly the idea of bringing India into the mix to try and put pressure on Pakistan. That’s a fairly new idea. I think those two things will have a small effect, but we’re not looking at a game-changer here. But we can at least stay in the game.”

On the Afghanistan endgame for the U.S.

“I think the best possible outcome we could achieve would be the following: a democracy, a nation that has minimalist but some control over its borders, keeping the Taliban out of the major population centers and over time, a political, diplomatic solution that brings the Taliban into a conversation about peace in Afghanistan, better than it is now. And the increase of troops at least allows us to move in some measure toward that outcome.”

On Trump saying the new Afghanistan strategy goes against his “original instinct”

“At the end of the day, the buck stops with the president of the United States. And he will own this war going forward.”

On adopting a more regional approach to North Korea

“What we need to do first of all, before we even get to the regional approach, is spend more time talking to our South Korean allies. They are our best source of information, and I would argue generally our best counselors in how to deal with the North. Then you build out from there, and that means getting Japan, most notably, but also Australia, New Zealand, Malaysia, Vietnam. We need to get this out of a conversation where it is today of the U.S. versus North Korea, and get it into a conversation of the international community and especially the region against North Korea.”

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Watch PBS Newshour:

newshour-logo-hires.pngMore News from PBSNewshour

News from PBS Newshour

Here’s how Republicans and Democrats feel about science news

Bill Nye leads the March for Science in Washington, D.C., on April 22, 2017. Photo by Michael Rios Republicans and...

Does Medicare make sense for seniors with employer health coverage?

In the past, writes journalist Philip Moeller, I usually told employees turning 65 that they did not have to get...

Senate Republicans say they’ll push ahead with plan to repeal Obamacare

U.S. Senator Lindsey Graham speaks to reporters about proposed legislation to repeal Obamacare at the U.S. Capitol...

WATCH: Obama speaks at global health event

Watch former President Barack Obama speak at the event on Wednesday. Former President Barack Obama spoke at the Bill...

WATCH: Melania Trump to UN: ‘Step up’ to protect children

Watch first lady Melania Trumps U.N. speech on Wednesday. NEW YORK — First lady Melania Trump on Wednesday called on...

WATCH LIVE: Day 2 of UN General Assembly debate

World leaders deliver speeches for a second day at the U.N. General Assembly in New York on Wednesday. You can watch...

U.S. to give $32 million for Myanmar’s Rohingya refugees

Rohingya refugees walk on a muddy path after crossing the Bangladesh-Myanmar border in Teknaf, Bangladesh, on Sept...

Facebook should testify in Russia probe, Senate intelligence chairman says

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg is seen on stage during a town hall at Facebooks headquarters in Menlo Park, California....

What’s in the new GOP health care bill, in one (simple) chart

Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., speaks about the Republicans new health care bill on Capitol Hill on Sept. 13, 2017...

Trump urges more nationalist worldview in first UN address

Watch Video | Listen to the AudioJUDY WOODRUFF: For President Trump today, a time to press a new world view and lay...

Powerful 7.1 earthquake will test Mexico’s emergency response

Watch Video | Listen to the AudioJUDY WOODRUFF: In another major story today: An earthquake shook Central Mexico...

First Irma, now Maria. Here’s how U.S. territories are preparing for disaster

Watch Video | Listen to the AudioJUDY WOODRUFF: As this afternoons earthquake struck Mexico, another hurricane...

AP Report: GOP tentatively agrees to $1.5 trillion plan on tax cuts

U.S. Senator Bob Corker (R-TN) talks to reporters as he arrives for the weekly Republican caucus policy luncheons at...

News Wrap: Senate Intelligence Committee cancels private interview with Trump lawyer

Watch Video | Listen to the AudioJUDY WOODRUFF: In the days other news: Senate investigators canceled a private...

Erdogan questions why U.S. has armed Syrian Kurdish ‘terrorists,’ disputes claims of dictatorship

Watch Video | Listen to the AudioJUDY WOODRUFF: Recep Tayyip Erdogan has led Turkey since 2003, first as prime...